19 months vs. life

On August 25, 2009, Nathaniel Craver died as a result of traumatic brain injury.  He had been adopted from Russia.  When he was hospitalized, doctors counted more than 80 injuries that were in various stages of healing.  They included previous fractures.

On July 2, 2010, Kairissa Mark also died from traumatic brain injury.  She had been adopted from China.  Doctors found that she had broken bones and bruises.

The Cravers spent 19 months in prison and were sentenced to time served.  Kairissa Mark’s adoptive mother, Deborah Mark, was sentenced to life in prison. 

Testifying for the prosecution, Dr. Wayne Ross told the jury that the boy’s legs were as thin as pencils, bruises covered his torso and back, and his brain showed widespread evidence of blunt-force trauma.

Dr. Ross continued his testimony, stating that that torn muscles around Nathaniel’s shoulders and pelvis, some of them fresh, indicated that someone yanked or pulled on him and finally shared with the jury that “severe, significant failure-to-thrive or starvation” contributed to the death of Nathaniel.

Source.  Michael and Nanette Craver said that Nathaniel died as a result of self-inflicted injuries.

The Cravers are seeking a new trial.

The head injury killed Kairissa two days after she was admitted to the hospital. But an autopsy found she had suffered far more trauma during her time with the Marks. Thirteen broken bones. Scars and bruises on her nipples and inner thighs.

Deborah Mark told investigators that, frustrated by the child’s behavior, she had hit Kairissa with sticks, shaken her, pinched and twisted her nipples and thighs, and finally flung her into her bedroom wall.

Source.

Both the Marks and the Cravers have other children.  The Marks have an older biological daughter, and the Cravers adopted Nathaniel’s twin.  She is now in the custody of Nanette Craver’s sister.

I’ve commented previously about sentencing disparities, and people who are not idiots understand that I am not suggesting that the murder of children is not a serious crime.

Edited to add: Steven Mark was a stay-at-home dad and apparently called the agency right before the child died.

Lowery said that in a June 30 phone call to the adoption agency, Steven Mark said: “Why did you send this demon child to me?’’

The Nashville director for Bethany Christian Services, which placed Kairissa with the Marks, said during testimony that a counselor emailed the Marks to set up a meeting but never got a response.

5 thoughts on “19 months vs. life

  1. I don’t think I have ever heard of an ap or anybody “pinching and twisting nipples”.. . I don’t understand how the agency or friends of the family didn’t take action either. And I thought that a special needs child would be required to have a special needs plan outlined, I would guess that never happened either.
    The Cravers starve the child to death and then say he self-inflicted? Unbelievable.

    What must the bio mother feel in these cases, it must be a huge devastation.

  2. These folks should all be doing life; they tortured their children to death. Amazing that the Cravers are requesting a new trial. They pretty much got away with murder (19 months!). Certainly no justice for Nathaniel…

  3. Meanwhile people with marijuana charges are spending years in jail. Our country is fucked. Who are these people that are allowed to adopt? Seriously, adoption agencies need some reform because they let just anyone with cash have a kid.

  4. I was shocked that the father called to complain about a “demon child” and that didn’t warrant an immediate home visit by Bethany Christian Services. The agency responded with an e-mail! WTF

  5. I wonder if Bethany Christian Services should be charged with negligence and endangering the welfare of a child. If the agencies who place these children were made responsible, maybe this child would have been saved. I always think of Masha, and how she was sent to a home without even her own bed, to me, this is social worker negligence.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s