Why they call it ‘institutional’

Via Colorlines:  “Georgia 3rd Graders asked what U.S. does to ‘illegal aliens'”

Does it:

a. Put them to work in the army?

b. Shoot them into outer space?

c. Put them to death?

or d. Send them back where they came from?

The homework assignment with this question came from edhelper.com, a subscription service that provides worksheets on a number of subjects for teachers.

I took a look over there to get an idea of its offerings.  There is a whole immigration unit on the website.  If your second and third graders missed the “What is an Illegal Alien?” worksheet (which you can view here), they can repeat in fifth to seventh grade.

There’s also a piece on “Immigrant to Citizen” for grades seven through nine:

Any person who is not a resident of the country being entered is called an alien. When an alien wants to stay for a period of time in another country, a visa must be obtained. A visa is an official stamp giving permission to enter a specific country. If a person enters a country without a passport or the necessary visa, that person is undocumented, or an illegal alien. If caught without the proper papers, an illegal alien will be sent back to the country from which he or she came.

There are two different kinds of visas. A nonimmigrant visa is given to people who are visiting a country as tourists. They may be on vacation or there for business. Normally, the alien is not allowed to get a job and work when using a nonimmigrant visa.

Where to start with this? The first sentence seems to contradict the term “resident alien.” And visas aren’t necessarily required by all countries. Plus a visa isn’t necessarily just a stamp, nor are there just two types of visas. But whatever. Explaining the CIS probably wouldn’t fit on a one-page worksheet.

The answer to the question, kiddies, is a., c., and d. As far as I know, we haven’t sent any undocumented immigrants to space yet.

12 thoughts on “Why they call it ‘institutional’

  1. I don’t understand how this question helps to educate children about immigration, documented or not. It makes no sense from an educational standpoint.

    And the answers are just stupid. The whole thing is just plain offensive. Why are teachers relying on dumbass worksheets like this anyway? No wonder our educational system is in ruins.

  2. Oh. My. God. My mouth is hanging open in shock– if you think the question is bad, read the “story” that precedes it, claiming to explain illegal immigration. Absolutely stunning.

  3. seems obvious to me that “shoot them” and “kill them” are dog whistles, these “education” sites are pathetic.

  4. Wow, that Sam kid is an asshole, but so’s his mom. I guess the apple doesn’t fall far from the tree.

  5. I volunteered at an Elementary school composed of mostly black and brown children a year ago. My tasks included making word puzzles and crosswords of the kids spelling words utilizing a function on that website. When I saw it on a colorlines (I believe it was) video I shook my head in irritation, not shock. The racism in the public school system here is quite obvious without teachers drawing on kids, or calling them slurs, so this assignment on this site makes perfect sense to me. I have to send this to the Chicana women I volunteered with there. We regularly talked about the “I” word while on duty.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s