Will French POCs finally be seen?

Let me be clear about this: I am not a fan of Nicolas Sarkozy, France’s “playboy” president. I would not have voted for him and I don’t normally agree with much he says.

But I have to agree with the statement he issued regarding his plan to collect voluntary data on race:

He said the lack of data on ethnic minorities was hampering the ability to measure inequality and deal with it.

Having lived in the country for over a decade and a half, I can assure you that racism is rampant. I also therefore agree with the race campaigners in the article who say that the society is “plagued by discrimination”. This is a country that only got its first primetime newscast journalist of colour this decade.

However, I really do not believe that any light can be shed on the extent of this discrimination until reasonably reliable statistics are produced. Unfortunately, many, many groups do not agree with me, including the ground-breaking SOS Racisme.

Recent news articles, like the one in the Guardian linked above, cite France’s “shame at its collaboration with the Nazis”. I absolutely believe this to be true. The French were no more anti-Semitic than the rest of Europe at that time, but the Vichy government actively collaborated with the German occupants, controlling its own population through a well-organised militia (La Milice) that modelled itself on the Gestapo. (This is not something that is widely known, and I first discovered it in Louis Malle’s 1987 film, Au Revoir Les Enfants.)

French society has never got over it. Never even dealt with it properly. After the war, it was easier to tar and feather (literally) a few poor girls who’d slept with German soldiers for whatever reasons, than to actively pursue those in charge. In the 1990s, the trials of Paul Touvier (regional head of the Lyon Milice) and later, Maurice Papon (in charge of “Jewish Affairs” in the Bordeaux area’s regional administration) caused a stir. People, especially Gen Xers and younger, were obliged to face the country’s dark past. And very uncomfortable they were with it too.

It is much easier to pretend that this is the country of Liberté, Égalité, Fraternité than to face up to Difference, Privilege and Discrimination. (Maybe I should suggest that as a new motto for France.) By avoiding the collection of data, we can safely shove it all under the rug and not worry about it.

In this current debate, it has also been said that “nobody should ever have to wear the yellow star again”, but the person who said that, (strangely, a politician of colour), forgets that those of us who are not white or who have “foreign-sounding” names wear that badge every single day. And like many Jewish people during that time, we are not or no longer ashamed of it. What we require is that it not be a reason to discriminate against us.

Opponents of the proposed measure say that statistics will not help in the fight against discrimination. And they may be right – per se. But one of the things I believe is important in the collection of statistics is to alert the general white population to the fact that we are not just talking about a handful of troublesome furriners here. We are talking about significant portions of the population, born and bred in this country, and contributing to its economy. To fight against discrimination, we need to be seen.

(On a final note, I abhor the way the Times and the BBC have referred to the measure as an “ethnic census”, effectively bringing back memories of the counting of Jews prior to rounding them up and deporting them to concentration camps. What is journalism coming to?)

6 thoughts on “Will French POCs finally be seen?

  1. This is great news. Racial “color blindness” must die! Will this actually go through?

    It reminds me of the United Nations claiming that Canada’s term “visible minority” is racist because “The use of the term seemed to somehow indicate that ‘whiteness’ was the standard, all others differing from that being visible”.

    So to him, if we are not called “visible minorities”, we wouldn’t be visibly minorities.

    I like your yellow-star badge metaphor for race.

  2. I have problems with this analogy. I think it diminishes the meaning of the yellow-star badge. The Holocaust was a unique event and needs to be respected as such. I’d say wearing a yarmulke or a hijab is a more appropriate analogy, although people aren’t necessarily born wearing either.

  3. @gabriel
    I think that the author is comparing the wearing of the yellow star as a marker of a Jewish Identity to the ways in which color creates certain bodies as “other”. He is not equating the present daily lived experience of POC to the holocaust.

  4. I don’t see how any one can disagree with having statistics. Even if they don’t help with the discrimination (which I doubt. I think on some level it has to) it is still helpful to know how large the minority population is. Not recognizing the minority population is racist and it sends the message that the minority population is either invisible or unimportant.

  5. gabriela and others,

    I just want to clarify that the politician in question was the one who made the comparison between the yellow star and statistics. One could interpret what she said as a reference to the fact that the Vichy government carried out an ethnic census in order to identify those who should wear the badge. However, this politician, a product of her French upbringing and a staunch feminist, was also very supportive of the banning of the hijab in schools.

    It seems to me that she believes that equality can only be attained through the eradication of difference. Which, of course, is illusory.

    In my argument against this, I chose to remember the feelings of Jews made to wear the star, who could not change the fact, but who drew comfort and strength from this identification.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s